ࡱ> g 2bjbjVV r<r<* 80<l4 -.###,,,,,,,$9.0n,###^##, ,Z(Z(Z(#,Z(#,Z(Z(Z(4&fZ(v,,0 -Z(Y2(XY2Z(Y2Z(##Z(#####,,Z(### -####Y2######### : CENTRE FOR FORENSIC SCIENCE M420, University of Western Australia 35 Stirling Highway Crawley WA 6009 T +61 8 6488 1232 F +61 8 6488 7285 [email] www.forensicscience.uwa.edu.au CRICOS Provider Code: 00126G 1st Floor, Myers St Building, Myers St, Nedlands, WA, 60091 February 2012 Age Assessment Inquiry Human Right Policy Team 鱨վ Level 3, 175 Pitt Street, Sydney, NSW, 2000. To the Human Rights Policy Team: I praise the recent decision (July 2011) by the Australian Government to introduce a range of alternative measures of assessing age in individuals whom have no documentary evidence of age and have entered into the Australian criminal justice system. These alternative measures include the use of dental x-rays, focused age interviews and seeking documentary evidence; these are, however, stated as being supplementary to the continued use of wrist x-rays. It is my understanding that the Gruelich & Pyle (1959 second edition) Radiographic Atlas is being used in Australia to interpret wrist x-rays submitted for the purpose of estimating age of undocumented illegal migrants (e.g. Indonesian people smugglers). If this is the case then the atlas is being inappropriately applied to a group of living individuals completely removed (genetically, environmentally and temporally) from the original study sample middle-class North American Caucasians born in the 1930s. Use of such a document will not only result in an increased degree of error and uncertainty in the age estimate, but it contravenes the original intention of the atlas as stated by its authors (p. 44 see Appendix) The assessments that I have personally viewed (public record of court transcripts) suggest that they are made without any calculation of the error associated with the derived age estimate; for example, it is simply stated that the assessed x-ray matched Male Standard Number 30 (Gruelich & Pyle, 1959:121) and thus the individual is estimated to be 18 years of age. It is a biological impossibility to estimate age using any skeletal element to that level of precision to do so ignores documented research into human variability (growth patterns, genetic and environmental influences, etc.) that encompass several decades of research, including that of my own group in the last several years. There is also an inherent error in interpreting the referred x-ray according to the standards outlined in any skeletal atlas there is considerable inter- and intra-observer error in making what is known to be a very subjective (individualistic) assessment. Appropriate training is required, and even then, five different examiners may all provide a different interpretation. Such errors need to be quantified and taken into consideration by any officer acting on behalf of the Australian Government. My groups research has shown that the general effect of applying foreign standards for estimating biological attributes in the human skeleton is a reduction in expected accuracy, the magnitude of which is proportionately related to the degree of dissimilarity (increasing biological distance) between the original reference sample and the individual to which those standards are being applied (Franklin et al. 2005; 2012a,b). Age assessments thus need to be performed using appropriate population-specific standards (statistical data); this holds true whether a hand-wrist system is used, or if (preferably) the dentition is studied. A multifactorial approach (e.g. use of multiple indicators of age, such as hand x-rays and the dentition) is preferable, but this is not without methodological issues that must be duly considered (see below). For example, there appears to be strong evidence showing that multifactorial techniques increase accuracy and help control for variation that may occur in any one single age indicator (Franklin 2010). There does not yet, however, appear to be any general consensus as to which methods should be combined, if they should be weighted, and how this can be achieved (Martrille et al. 2007; White & Folkens 2000). It is also important to consider that age assessment in living individuals has become a routine element of forensic practice in many countries and there are established recommendations for the most appropriate diagnostic analyses (e.g. Schmelling et al. 2008). It is thus worth considering published suggestions that radiographic examination of the clavicle can provide further useful information for assessing if an individual is of a criminally responsible age, particularly when hand ossification appears complete. The clavicle is forensically important because of it is one of the last bones in the human skeleton to fully ossify, usually in the early to mid-twenties (e.g. Kreitner et al. 1998; Schulz et al. 2005; Kellinghaus et al. 2010); similar observations have been quantified in Western Australian individuals (Franklin et al. unpublished data). The solution to the aforementioned issues are (on paper) simple: support appropriately qualified entities that have an established track record, and the required specialists and infrastructure to evaluate appropriate methodological approaches with the aim of formulating statistically quantified standards for age estimation in living individuals. Such research will need to abide by appropriate ethical guidelines for research involving living persons. Other important considerations are typically related to the finished product (age estimation standards), which as outlined by Ritz-Timme et al. (2007) should fulfill the following specific demands: (i) they must have been presented to the scientific community through peer-reviewed publication; (ii) their accuracy must be tested using valid statistical procedures and described by clearly defined terms; (iii) the method must be accurate enough for routine forensic application. An important issue still remains (amongst several that in the interest of brevity I will not consider in this submission) that should be considered by the Commission concerns regarding the definition of an officer under Section 5 of the Migration Act (1958). Age assessments should be performed by appropriately qualified individuals with the required skill base; the resulting estimation must not only be able to withstand legal challenge, but it must be cognizant of the humanitarian implications of an erroneous result. To that end, the most logical officer is one who has specialized training in the disciplines of forensic anthropology and/or odontology. An intimate knowledge of basic human anatomy, whilst certainly necessary, is simply not enough; there needs to be a clear awareness of a methods limitations, how to appropriately calculate the degree of uncertainty in the final estimation, a clear understanding of the influence of human biological variation and other extrinsic factors on the final estimation, and how to appropriately prepare a submission when called to act as an expert witness in an Australian court of law. Forensic practitioners are typically appropriately trained in the aforementioned criteria. To that end, I strongly urge the Commission to evaluate who is, and should be, performing the age estimations of those individuals who illegally enter Australia without documentary evidence of their date of birth. For Western Australia, the Centre for Forensic Science (UWA) has the capacity to offer suitable age assessments (providing access to the required standards is provisioned see above); on the east coast there are other suitable institutions (e.g. Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine). I look forward to the final report of the Commission and trust that the end result is to the direct benefit of ensuring accurate and appropriate ethical decisions concerning individuals whose legal age is in question. Yours sincerely, A/Prof. Daniel Franklin Director of Studies Appendix: Quote from Gruelich and Pyle (1959) If an evaluation of a technique is to be meaningful, however, it must be made with due regard to the limitations inherent in it. No method that is at present available or, we believe, that is likely to be devised will make it possible to assess a hand-film with pin-point precision. The system described in this atlas, for example, is intended to provide merely useful estimates of skeletal status and it will do so, if it is properly used. Unfortunately, as in many other procedures, there is a tendency to attribute to, and expect from, a greater degree of precision than was intended by the nature of the changes which it is designed to measure (1959:44). References: Franklin, D., Freedman, L., and Milne, N. 2005. Sexual Dimorphism and Discriminant Function Sexing in Indigenous South African Crania. Homo: Journal of Comparative Human Biology, 55 (3): 213-228. Franklin D. 2010. Forensic age estimation in human skeletal remains: current concepts and future directions. Legal Medicine 12:1-7. Franklin, D., Flavel, A., Kuliukas, A., Hart, R., and Marks, M.K. 2012. The Development of Forensic Anthropological Standards in Western Australia. 64th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences. Atlanta, Georgia. February 20, 2012a. Franklin, D., Flavel, A., Kuliukas, A., Oxnard, C.E., and Marks, M.K. 2012. Cranial sexual dimorphism and anthropological standards: preliminary investigations in a Western Australian population. 64th Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Forensic Sciences. Atlanta, Georgia. February 20, 2012b. Gruelich WW, Pyle SI. Radiographic atlas of skeletal development of the hand and wrist. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1959. Kellinghaus M, Schulz R, Vieth V, Schmidt S, Schmelling A. Forensic age estimation in living subjects based on the ossification status of the medial clavicular epiphysis as revealed by thin-slice multidetector computed tomography. Int J Legal Med 2010;124:149154. Kreitner K-F, Schweden FJ, Riepert T, Nafe B, Thelen M. Bone age determination based on the study of the medial extremity of the clavicle. Eur Radiol 1998;8:11161122 Martrille L, Ubelaker DH, Cattaneo C, Seguret F, Tremblay M, Baccino E. Comparison of four skeletal methods for the estimation of age at death on white and black adults. J Forensic Sci 2007;52:302-7. Ritz-Timme S, Cattaneo C, Collins MJ, Waite ER, Schutz HW, Kaatsch HJ, Borrman HIM. Age estimation: the state of the art in relation to the specific demands of forensic practice. Int J Legal Med 2000;113: 129-36. Schmelling A, Grundmann C, Fuhrmann A, et al. Criteria for age estimation in living individuals. Int J Legal Med 2008;122:457460. Schulz R, Muhler M, Mutze S, Schmidt S, Reisinger W, Schmeling A. Studies on the time frame for ossification of the medial epiphysis of the clavicle as revealed by CT scans. Int J Legal Med 2005;119:142145. White TD, Folkens PA. Human Osteology. San Diego: Academic Press, 2000.      t % * + , - ~  վxqmimeaVh^JhnR^JaJhcB_hnhbh^J h1hn h1h4 h1hhhO:hhhZ h1hW8EhhAh &hCh~CJH*hCh~CJ aJ mHsHhCh~CJmHsHhCJmH sH hCh~CJmH sH hChz CJmH sH hCh~CJhdh~    (Nbt &$&#$/Ifb$gdCx$&#$/Ifb$gdC$&#$/Ifb$gdCP$&#$/Ifb$gdC    + , NIIgdlkd$$Ifl 0| t 6644 lae4pytC$&#$/Ifb$gdCP$&#$/Ifb$gdC &P$&#$/Ifb$gdC, - D \  xy/0vwdhgd0wldhgddhgdB@dhgd#/dhgd[Adhgd^J@&gdd x   V a Awxy+Xwx2w-./0;Trsÿÿûÿ÷ûûdzdzdzǯǫÞǚǓ hhh'Hh!!hCJ^JaJh hYzhB@hch,hlh[AhhACJ^JaJh[A^JaJhB@^JaJhYz^JaJh^J^JaJh^Jh 8^JaJ:s6HRS#-v$);M\]z ҿh!!h0wl5CJaJh!!h%` h0wlh0wlh&Xh0wlhchYzhn/hz@ hB@h#/h#/h Bh hhBh"###%%&&&&&&&''''C'D')))))dhgdYzdhgdDdhgd!! hl!"# ,#n####$$%&&&&&&'''B'C'D')))|qmihz@hYzhYzhYz^JaJhYzCJ^JaJ hD5 hYz5hhDh~hcB_hDhcB_aJ h &aJ hDaJ h0_2aJ h aJ h*^JhFTh BH*^JhFTh B6^JhFTh B6]^JhFTh B^J h B5 hYz5hYzhYz5-)**5+6+4,5,b-c---..//a0b071811122222 $7$8$H$a$gd%` $7$8$H$a$gdz@ $7$8$H$a$gd B01$171811111111111111(2)2i2j2y22222222222222222222ά᨟wijhUmHnHu"jhUmHnHsH tH uh%hjh%hUhFTh B5^JhFTh%`^JhFThz@^Jhz@hz@5\^Jhz@hz@^Jhyyhyy5\^Jhyyhyy^J hyy^J hz@^J h B^JhFTh B]^JhFTh B^J)222222222222222Tgd< $7$8$H$a$gd B2222hFTh B5^Jh%hh9 0&P 1h:p. A!"#$% @=VsL:<]m8-mUxx;;ww Rږ J)iK$HK`eAIʽ}oMh~Y~ a}/h3ş$qJ{C^x 6V?qe FSQS>Iy6wʿSwۀ،N;kAuVuU-dS/1֫|B(MeUgq^>â^tljAE/ C1Q٘3ޅ؆mێb{S$qö1ނRY)%L$M4|CbW֋i`%cY%RYvgo+LIx c12fe,^L4MwO͙9y722sL4I ,̴Lux#1=,K9uecɁXr!LLt<,ٟ(U9ۜkywUζbQC~ő7Gȣ#{mt/ ޽0]\6c}70C,G9}qW8bGq~~ߦ \v3|ٽVl vrxw36! }%c{36be9Y6b9kα2XC|'Ś7usZLa5g "H23#Hx` %"'^Af _8ljY=E&d^N#ܳSL<31smҞ2yYLDL`M%(;D\!/./"ssQuP;(^9"!ZPnAyFa4XAvlV6mn1ҳc!? :u:y'ǪTVhg` 7-{ea Vb)Y/lNyyb_폮Ni6S-菡N31 s00>ӿi9i%v0,!hhڨ($Re{,kKĒ drd c6a1Os6srv-gP,Z\mrvUgO'g#ȳ9M L L'g`Pc1X(s2,o~N3ϙ"rɴv+ 9;or7sd;}=N?-vH`\9$έ zy#y`6ۧ_YkYe #,LTLLB,XbKc,ey1i>y1ZYijBUֶ,k[H^sYuC>E|X8W~,gs}g5Vf9vs L JMjsu}ruUCX<,w yxQ{DeQrqwQ;YTƊJuDe&m(("ȇ#N}؃]؁mn߈ϼ1cHw`cQpH;hC_K}b0c6MɖxQ>,&aO_OͶ>h2L6%SYUj ؗ#յ$Ug[ɼgL4~t_P/deQ ~yD~Nx7?y5k}>ukV_ԍ|x{0nrHD#!,5QòEDp|A,jqs iz|f~_O9NugNĻg29ad ga>>+ʫ)ŲώcXK~Ʊݳ崡l̵'ʲM,0ĹDMPl&ij꼹>B/< Wnz:1M2SX=$uMe]oq>NcY8x8i+o"Yn&q/Y`HE})ǯ Jm.o÷G8}'|xwD@AABA@~a9}D0⡾Fd}%4gXlFS{O5i8oX\qqqE k% Oᢞ>$>\$Lh2:1X_%B*qk]u\%_ ZiAiӕA}!hmItaCάYg֯cP}00 -񈳌 P׷]tK4c&FEC[[&>=| OEʍx9⭼|9EV %QrETG*ؔE_wm͏&u.Uc ٞ?J>7g5:Qz)| ZP/uj6iqOˎj3ok]-?ݬ:\ysox[>B$<{阂1$Ra<@?o"NIco1lN9,›%1oc i(/Z6vl|oQwX-V3_E[=؂Xk_uf 5lְUgMv1];vl#.[oD `S>8|p_8lj3h?8c18Ca6u8~4/$L̽'C؏؂Mhy6a3`c'좿w3݌g7 Hkt6=v.0 I ?T:E8Q"(RÏ*B]4D#K<(ljzC[Po%O'o92Ad bkz5u$`c8[Ad@zgkSΣs(18Qȏ¥I}vFwS~k;|pgK>:j#$- Ñ*}/^BVV*8gpZ))D8S8$x;JD&"$w~=qOˎ0٠L꾈+F6UD\7#%px'Nؖ@#3e7i!q؏خ%۴Vl$پY;el.*!؄͖kJ+9;k]:7U| @Χ:`F4ho4vM 1lı%Z5XYZhz U)GY5%RP i_ux"ylꢚB.UF%T@y#(G=JTEj E*5E[FK4GiL7bO#whK)쯂b$} a/rۣW01 3"b:bMo[xEC --mdk3 Yw0S1r25~1x #(H9a?oьc4Mx_c8oVScYuWNq"~J⹜. K%%b:MZ0sqwHpW@9WYR8BUư;~a/] Ym]؃8&s 'r!7Џ_%7r!~<ŻuQܔl?>%/[Ac 8r$@1 x(oq;F.r0\ثq8ۇ= /XL/Ѳ_k,Uj^8W3jb9[ë;&Wq-kS!OQQS^Tڢ!Z#zyjl)-z@S#$q9mx=ۖ8AO`+1荞a9SO"i 1 81Ap}<DS]Fs4@mO%QSVTA&<5Bnگ¼gj$P;$N((xّr(2r 'r#/d^W!-DG!SȓYE^?j~\|0ȋ*/̟'/߀Şdc 1ٓ[lq'RD?ȓ?qR 5}#/-0.x%\\\UWw8?N؏kH4a?0i㞿Oqp(ӓ]l7'B rƇ2"SC`e xQF/r1#1cXq7~zo1+~޼d _@S]7 |F3nVhtҊ1Dcԣ\5Qr9Ei5$ePPi*T{F'/ -s7T狼' >XyE9QS,RZb+va9-2=TN*633b VSg r,$e /ś@NBnlvKnBNd;8nWGqmW}K؈-`uIF-c ~l߂6;vrπ0v(;)=6v?ȭ]NlڎLX(%RN4C|>'O?EscY5h1 Hor|v\rvV9{N\'gkWppDkHG0dDZt9HdzGү8$PH.C)eS-\z^ED&ȡWyQ~ 1Au԰DZ"[PUPˈ\z!Q.rȯ᱑_ȥ'9F&֯m\|q_"D.2qA^ /n7ȋ% 5N2B?\>dUS?s! }$3wNdֽ"\$(Qb`>B, *Ke%ǯ2,|A?"]D"`p]e}΋/X%u\ -,XӯP 0 LT~阁YMs1|83/ -'>W?$QE'^lj8AKe9gpW۸c$u$2\K{/1K~ϸ%s]Mb>n W-$>l;6#6+33̚~7]ڹѵ.$0<" -ֹ ;Ju~:g_"j[uJ*򢲯 J(r((T(GD-4D BkKǷDs4Ec4W~}QWl 'uFowifXhĠ%uF_tюr+D ~6نG_n} gEeȥ+EA:ۯeir((D +Ȅ)'=Ȃl_ Qu`sJ6_Uuǚ-J! 㬏_,Gg">KW#Dm;T}bm,#Xy#d}UaFZCyj\E}:ZuS>@iCET&6/ 'X#%7r!')U^uEyCm#$ |(ʨjw70"Pb-4j_ï*W,5ATUQzّ^;)'7Nwp4NBb} 'ҋbrisXM~}<k==[cW,s*g^ K4sTުSZN;+#ZQN՗ˌcsacX+x}:hLE1296ZEw}P|e`d|%e%XR/_IbW 7 f~̯8:1#:3lLCPanȶ =-C1c07eXh7}1ԍͯi|Ϫr2-ߛ{s.sIװtDY|ϨkFRIW&˓ĩ hD6eMf`i4Ac7 P? 5PxUc_5U^%k CShK%ےm_3['Wsh'~~9i#+׸pb/kaƥ3ȁ\ 2Ḇ 1?SA%/s19 -чrW܌9TPrQZ1'Sqb{)"cI`P6+zhwsMj^DAtD'y:N[ \ҹ5 -~>L28GwD)Q>c8f D#opM}1w-<ȇiPY$rW"ފ8mQg?鸯qa>=N&~R-hmva!7uJ[9sk"衵j)֪7xkU\Ʒ/Q,+ɟrvb7mU~=5=RTՐq=G9e=ʲ܋߰f Vk|%@+0ԫ"Wr\L?#OXwr沎sY{<}4G",ů7a a;L;8v'm&X>rŴ{(frm }oF~Ə+ٶ˱z_c_ȩzs/XMemo6}XM݌-VKށqXn1v;ضuԟ{)caXo|}Yh֢^_vһvmEkٚy&m9ڣ+=9 f֍:]296ZУpJzq^a!`\%$c,){S_-yb^#^W]E"ȯ:ĸ TqfJEQ)f{I2zgYNפ;~ֶo*892sC墯\41K,(*GUSV^c(_%W~UC$걭fcΙԈRϾ= j-|oH4f|g@#r9V_GT}u[U[ŶHD 6=g/}g68晷|m#v=]ܱpvhfT>6qW8]U:o j-e$/xGȋޑ%/yǰm mQwWA#vNb/pws^?eNCzı'ϐuYLY&(3땙zgBFX+',e9LT&r2c‰v8 = j> ^Ϳyx%GQv_;vƿld^6oG8㼡7|OZ{.F[?yb F߉flNh%)=zb8>ds} wy\$Wc\"Wx!5(GEowc6}yWʶes)\9|B|ji/Kb_zcGo2J~Ll>",gMV{ȺF_ khk_b1u0}XՌu ksm 볆l5sXe%C?}aռ͟$v3to9[ON6iïUƛx^'xo1ZUBNLNLl^&.~5ifqgr&i'm kKVh4 20_S{YL<ҘuQG%6s)>ޔ~hh)<&{]O{ֵ ihN9skN ڒSuḞc迯7lae>kOݑ[^c؀գzE=֠!oVBL{R1eP$vݨߝ=0m?6Ùi <}YhC_חmѬPk88!~2i RwsZWb֏}\My?!Y,1%ȑ"y> 9*3S~ З)?<Ȋpg¹>dT2= NN j-sɃpb#&bc؆##2Qz^AT*ESETBeX~*gQ\*L[9N1GiTڋ`j^5Xw *VP2)`_7tn[X"C5bQvIVjri!/zڡ=:KeOymC2|/pSuNɌ|q-mvw=]Owyҍ-ЌMw(6G=)ib,,1;i(f;im:uT-Bf,8fqX@Va=i* q?1.lV⽕}[=9۲uہ=ߍvb1b|Gm֓>VEck=Qr\#Wzrm5_c)X?'_",&K4Vl*2=1#Ql/yD+}ZwޯbRb_Za z\M_s Ÿ~O14|i,e_B}l'嵲ʕk;36dcXQiF8{^4c9~ #c8c8Mvi#(뵵F$bS K>Ǡ?P ˌi<׉ ˘`*1Ʃ3>dzVkkO; L ڛM{s9u8x?}dr2g߳lu6Xf3Yb-:m PV Zy*,yj6zcbӐgOMS+9ZQnHo$3eKm|x^]=ewO${1~ϸ{+XrK9=ͩko~`?1*nukEc)PύuwGD3n"2.Pnh%/ZZKh3L0ȃ򐻟6̘'93sgXw3{[Wnki)pp @cz3N#svﻲvD E7uvR]edwwY^Eחșĩ1qjB|)-ܣ1J&^ɳnۗ8g\0CP e~i?p }=փ6ۺҧ(K7F="/zhkk05ǺC kSG[[Ӈ~EL#P50Ss0k]s0*FQU&}d#M5Q՘K%)(e>OۙF@$(b6\ܲϟٳ<.㭍Z|z9lW2qcgZHk/Fzud8gFwMjѿ8smr mX=;}1})/yɵYvdZ`J&^} g6BqF*(fhyg)\|D9hm^ӆMPlyy:u cs}yB2GSAΦ'gȈL!;^7K8yNd$3sp7GnǼ~r#3u8m|>=Rmk_~9 qƧwTx6;Љx߷NM>vunԴVh)]Z Ak,ZulZ_)KhUD^[v!f) jd*-іm]e'lyFKΝvCa6IXzirLij[ jʌf:M&2SkU\隇AK 02/hrS5_fsMY\dfL̑E]t}(K>"|%˂ Das<&/8K3rُm}_^򴳫-VRgyʙ_Gny$v>Χ"̕N.]fw]Ed)WyYU]w5e\\-ъQ#򩃫t&-~599{N΃pub ᵃ:2,\j. YQk>[뚊 S0|\"o8blLe_W#X^)%\2t2 -LvfM&9=Sgmspl!yY\p}g)8#t6vKo\u;FgZ 7rɳ_^{^:\..D 2D DS5ʬW[++keqmפ)63e-5-c3Sּ.[rOouԜkRZ̩4\Qi;PUE]}dy*ƓwojZ- \sMr eP9]]e}׋p4{S֣{mΛ85io;~,㷌q 'sX]dmjʺZِLS4q/mtH{r2܋jed9,qjlŴ27p5>g ԵrOJ/.j96qwzYu|WG.~TR9D곭 ZcL^uyk`=G/Y/2>o۵!m⬇yϮEpϪ/fSs(u$8 Sk5%M48Ͳ6 ߦ<a 3$^!&c78^cgBRFaq8HlQԉy7dLm!~sl_Rkl2SNbf5+u90Gk8yy!?O8%^_+mϿ xvloS4ֺ3iiPM@V:)|5&^yT`xƪ LANcטSO_y/YRTr||ZH>,Ws F*<# 3h]}mLe4\}ekԥ`󢨣%vog|P2}:#kQX[GsN}J|S$M-N9 6|A9TТQ%m>4REbmLӅ's%5&F 6}Dc-*o9MgT@T~7n:UUZ>ӵZ%lװ/kəS<+.:ۋ sN _}f4Vח:a'2xE>R}_A)O.p=x=%kU״*kh:Kvc+}WϚMe:(iT״GvMs ϜG36γApm~ 6y,GHzFKTs}_A&CC}磠{6;)s޶NO =mz}j^s/v>VckRH;\y_s⼫K*tlZQA+{ lV#q:`7Ͽa^x3mKmy^^Cc6v b+8B>ټ4հǩ<5֙Gjcs3zi-(9Oy:(ΝTs>ݯw 0䠩n59]uyojfJKa;޷Gc f|nt7LuΧW|91xgHnas rITG$9^ -(b{{ bwG|TS%m|]εJP98M9C6vO!Ҝ 9[ڛdˮJf0v_otFS<өI^9srwsjsɱoDCf?}@98&SF>5w:5Dh m>Ҫ紳6DS8ɀ0<4B$%_ RyA9]l Ү"YRWvM_9_?ɼ5'3?nNi,MߥOi{-P~I HWKسҗ1N\M5PygPQr&'p2M5sbnuO.s:]y.N<tT:XJ'tF+=xvyѦ %ƳJ@[YڱD|~J8"NlPq*EE40З1r%Βgɡo?㪭*>|VKy?oDoʽi7+HcWz~,U؟>nRH-ĵNѬW(#9~0cFX..1x >:AA = 渡1!=A6i6唑ok A'6Yǂ:u~@nNX:YN3'l.s~}ڲ-M+hI-駅^1烶$OLc9httI=C7#Quj9u6p2׀)ُ}^Sv>W_ 1=yf gMroWlnv\???]Snlv~l=}k/pڅ6lp6Q#yqN;y`L)Rq8}Kc[  B\J|w83V#53 1)%X28RȀ0qgc=D(F )p6~^#zDJ3+##ko?Xҋ}[Se:4s9ڇ Hdy.Q/9W9 Ț\+'xGeqY8cx4RŹ-9"}\5g)Ew0;r=un?ZunyVγvו6p06-xfgmy~g'젮ycK es[Iƨ|hn{>Nq3sYΕ#l6,4IؿTo{?iy?X,'k'q9γY$N'y;k3h&o\پ]u 5r/ m.*8]w ln[.Qm=[:/̷g$~IG9w=֓Փգ&Fh o?7]i u-5m`GڈP M@5(M-;EDNsiuHP7"&*@S%wKE8eƃtQEm Q킈4zocmOg#N #C\v4!&0m5mlLo͹q;#87ܸ=mn@}!\ß`>ΏˬK ju=Q1{K*u}/PvzWaG"7QaOϛ_վȭ>.i5ʳ$i&|Oda) BiL)k|~RXJcSj`A!xT :,~ 3_~x[Gu|}i p;(pypzy5P(u5y S~]GnP<ΰu0H?ghaiwPe'\/6wУ>܎߄2DÍ,ģ N 9/|Gy^#XrmF9g.8Uqۙ:gtAhto~m 6AF%"m=Cy!8%Pιܔ ~ z 'uNO6( ME61@6<ϵe?F֗dd>ڦqX?C%U 5\Ve$wd,P#$I9ِ3(Uo@JDA2X+aHK&Y%_<+ِ!S ߥtrޗ~臼~z6IBV/}ž޲z h73}g0Ӱc"v}ʇg2 f\qX2FB>֩Q20951Fv!w7r_D̵ɔMj:uf:>9yd5dX0+h3fP!Ly_%kjRJ'"魒J(U6?fyOmjpd-/J^We:&T1ue10V/|0]3U^|vyHU7UvU2Nnt+6{d#lUeH8at8:$EPꠔQkGo~6碪YY]_EΉjNB|#ש[G_uA-!#n4Jss0sN3[,#fyz:e)} *}!N/3Eza,%M,n13Y+ ҤNCHY47WK;jk(d_"m6 `$ƜC9}uBxМ w]Ws6 ݠ;<Ax!z0!|FXOB@&_a>w3q0ϣ(ṉgvMv}s22Wxiʜ*-v[hS6$if~\- ^ef-κ$_^;6SC =S|nU? e+6v{6MC^E|2/ė bK>4r.ٳkݩݯ@'7?x:;.鰨Զٲڈ?`ͺ#3I\t+{쳞==+kEbYeC|}˱`c{)v9w]ضv9srr>lþte߃ھo] ;M+O1Cg:W{XAQ3VeeQʹB}.n6o2ȥׁ bSi򨞷V]g '"d1qJѳ ?ʰPJ>RbzRw7rh$,f"ljkA{QM}r7H!c~)9/HƞC \q~mgY1iYkgFb*l-uco2g"`ZL?_SG%N.@Ͻ,bLzq=@,K`/'[}k}wx˦n& a$kj8ki02τY?â4t<_ѭkS1'5}lb_q0 \ kC-ϋyBrd@@ܯC?~ ]+C ٗ\v;؜HLO$'E{͜@=cea#o`f'}Z0ăąi ǘdLc1J}ߦrqwpK.j԰}l6-O3c>%~e>c]cN#YǯĮjX%XHݹI0>&K0'mB,z͠~$HDO$KB/An2Y,,)_k h~b*P46 "A&dQrkkSN"[dTXi5U;>hvIu.=5/ZYbGk?G @=o;_ML3*kpV9 =xڭklEgw|zIRJP1  ҢP ` PԵ""b PLX?L4iЄhxDChi1Dm,P¼Ųfv L䜙ol@)4OVbCJRԜwb+m_,?JjKSj $ V"TJTETZQ*ͻm0὾,ԳҴԳQ?*αP⳦%Ŗ-<3 rbݧCJ!Q3R_xq^ݤu#k;Mwxym,L2_f.'k]O@{ID2AE\#>¸>n:?鑶ٱ=L9\\"$咄2'ѷɷ,۷13+rlՒ6뻰[fʫ!mɯI"ݳ%11պ찪O!ܟ<4فkh,www{'RN% =35SpL_f")!`8m@yd[yq^Q?x$3#pʌoi 202U8ifO3<( $YCrüs3.f^O{t54M\BN v"{Qz-%YEH=zҟ=WY/(W_p~A"͌F)ְ>2c$ !)O^rC$y@/yH*񄴽)޵߻UDb`}"qۋJחX^)I`nEp)liV[]1M<OP6r=zgbIguSebORD۫qu gZo~ٺlAplxpT0+[}`jzAV2Fi@qv֬5\|ʜ̭NleXdsjcs7f W+Ն7`g ȘJj|h(KD- dXiJ؇(x$( :;˹! I_TS 1?E??ZBΪmU/?~xY'y5g&΋/ɋ>GMGeD3Vq%'#q$8K)fw9:ĵ x}rxwr:\TZaG*y8IjbRc|XŻǿI u3KGnD1NIBs RuK>V.EL+M2#'fi ~V vl{u8zH *:(W☕ ~JTe\O*tHGHY}KNP*ݾ˦TѼ9/#A7qZ$*c?qUnwN%Oi4 =3N)cbJ uV4(Tn 7_?m-ٛ{UBwznʜ"Z xJZp; {/<P;,)''KQk5qpN8KGbe Sd̛\17 pa>SR! 3K4'+rzQ TTIIvt]Kc⫲K#v5+|D~O@%\w_nN[L9KqgVhn R!y+Un;*&/HrT >>\ t=.Tġ S; Z~!P9giCڧ!# B,;X=ۻ,I2UWV9$lk=Aj;{AP79|s*Y;̠[MCۿhf]o{oY=1kyVV5E8Vk+֜\80X4D)!!?*|fv u"xA@T_q64)kڬuV7 t '%;i9s9x,ڎ-45xd8?ǘd/Y|t &LILJ`& -Gt/PK! ѐ'theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsM 0wooӺ&݈Э5 6?$Q ,.aic21h:qm@RN;d`o7gK(M&$R(.1r'JЊT8V"AȻHu}|$b{P8g/]QAsم(#L[PK-![Content_Types].xmlPK-!֧6 0_rels/.relsPK-!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xmlPK-!0C)theme/theme/theme1.xmlPK-! ѐ' theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsPK] *@N  s )022!"$&, )22 #%  /X"$sL:<] V;N"$;_ML3*wG      @ 5% 8c8c     ?1 d0u0@Ty2 NP'p<'pA)BCD|E||s " 0e@8:8: 8:8: 8:8: 8:8: 8:8: 8:8:  8:8: 8:@ABC DEFGHIJK5%LMNOPQRSTUWYZ[ \]^_ `abN 5%  N 5%  N    5%    !"?N@ABC DEFGHIJK5%LMNOPQRSTUWYZ[ \]^_ `ab [޴p6"Kc@Z B(    N? "H@`?NNN?N  S RA4 Block PMS_with tag 190210C"`?  S :A CFS CMYK LogoC"`?0(  B S  ? ^Q%dj.u@1j@QY *2D#J#P#X#C$I$O$W$c%k%%%&&&&|&&&&&&&&&' '''''%'|''''''''''''''N(Q(g(l(p(x((((((())8)B)F)O)S)[)))))))))))j*m************** mr!!!"6#}#~### $$1$5$$$:%M%`%y%%%&&&''V(]())-)))~***************3333333333333333333333**w T*f  5%` ({ w hU0}9}S.T]"qDAPvkz w)!I!WN!)" #1#U#o$:c?B@A B-B1B.C,EW8EVH}HPIH(K{L NSNUrP3QnRFT U|W!AX;2YdZ$J[U\W\=]G^cB_`}`bb&bSbdYRdT[d{ud!-ef(hiwi5k}Sk0wl>p_rsGuKwu?wJwKaxyYzUrzxz|{1&|@s}d~&Xyy~[Xh,K@O:C i]s X?\w?{^y I]4a^J%hyy:nT~Id:Rq[$+b!!+IIiJ# NvlQn/3/>qCV[bZw9n4W^OHPAkAG[Cl1CZd/! 5v3z@\> ^ Z}h?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTVWXYZ[\^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvxyz{|}~Root Entry F4 Data U1Table]Y2WordDocumentSummaryInformation(wDocumentSummaryInformation8MsoDataStore *44NH4EOJWOJ0==2 *4g4Item  PropertiesSVSRBNSP0LPELYA==2 *44Item  :PropertiesBX0UESPH55C==2 *44Item PropertiesO  !"#$& This value indicates the number of saves or revisions. The application is responsible for updating this value after each revision. DocumentLibraryFormDocumentLibraryFormDocumentLibraryForm   F Microsoft Word 97-2003 Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89qCompObj%r